specialized phenom vs power
So, while the base of the Power Mimic is still cut out, it is covered by a layer of foam that maintains a depressed center but also provides soft support. 3. I also noticed that the Power Arc definitely tapers to the nose quicker than a Scoop/Spoon, so there is definitely more real estate for the larger thighed gent. | Terms and Policies, Thule introduces Thule Caprock the roof platform designed to support all adventures, Team Toyota Specialized rides to victory at The Absa Cape Epic. Im already looking around the used market for spares. Katherine Moore is Dartmoor-based gravel and bikepacking expert who judges her rides by stoke level, rather than speed. The Power Arc is intended to provide better hamstring clearance. Just say when and how. Electric Bikes. Try 6 issues of Cycling Plus magazine for just 9.99 | SAVE 74% today. It was just a shame that the finish started to wear away after a few hundred kilometres of riding. It was a really bold and arresting design choice and I immediately loved it. Thanks for all the feedback It's solidly built and not too heavy. This new edition adds MIMIC technology and shortens the nose of the saddle to create a ride similar to the Specialized Power with an added 3mm to the nose. Pruitt, who is also known for his work with Specialized on the Body Geometry fit system, studied changes in female physiology over time on the bike. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. But when on the drops and putting power to the pedals its the best ive tried so far. The Power Pro Elaston with Mimic is like a (slightly) more affordable version of that, but the welcomed squish comes with a bit of movement in the padding at the nose that, to some, will feel like a lack of support. The Power Pro comes in two colour options, an all-black option with subtle logos or for 10 more it comes in Specializeds Chameleon finish. WebCHECK OUT INSTAGRAM FOR BEHIND THE SCENES AND ALSO GIVEAWAYS FOR SHIRTS!!! When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Tough, lightweight, and water-resistant Micromatrix cover. Im curious what the life of the soft foam will be. I just find they last longer, justifying their higher price. 130mm. Not tried the Phenon but the Romin Evo works for me on the road and feels a bit more versatile for different positions compared to the power but not quite as good for in the drops. The last big material innovation in saddle design happened decades ago with the introduction of foam. So , as much as I love the Power saddle on my MTB , not 100% sold on the road bike yet !! The Print+ membership where Singletrack magazine drops through your door, plus full digital access, is normally 45, now only 22.50 with the code. If don't move alot on your saddle then go with the power saddle. If you move alot then go with the Phenom. I even switched my road saddle to Phenom My overuse injury sits within my hip and hamstring, which has proven stubborn to healing and general treatment. If you move alot then go with the Phenom. FACT carbon fiber shell is flex-tuned for support and ride compliance. 256. But if you see the review of these two saddles, you can find the losers and the winner for your bike. The plastic carbon obtained shell and the still rails lifted up to all the misuse. Such a personal thing. The rails give 5cm adjustment, be careful when shuffling the saddle to the right position as the black finish, and adjustment markings, will easily scratch off making saddle adjustment more of a guessing game. Save 25% + DMR Trail Gloves + DeathGrips when you subscribe to MBUK magazine, *Spring Savings* Try 6 issues of Cycling Plus for just 9.99 | Save 74% today, The new Phenom Pro is highly comfortable, supportive, lightweight and without short snagging potential. We are here to provide proper information on specialized romin vs phenom and help you to choose with your findings. I have 6 of them or so. The two saddles are subtly different and are intended for different styles of riding, but also have a lot in common, so you might want to read both my reviews before making a choice. I've really struggled with this issue in the past, and finding a saddle that prevents it is a big relief in more ways than one. WebThe Phenom Expert was designed for comfort and strength over long days on the road or trail. Like many of Specializeds saddles, there are two threaded points for use with the companys range of SWAT accessories, such as the MTB and road Bandit straps which replace a saddle bag. Its Body Geometry design, meanwhile, caters to both men and women and helps to deliver superior performance in all seating positionsespecially aggressive ones. The Phenom was designed ground-up as an off-road saddle. The shape does not look so much different to a Scoop radius from what I can see, apart from the a central channel. Or sign up for one year for just 49 $79 59, Try your first month for just 1 / $1 / 1. Save 25% + DMR Trail Gloves + DeathGrips when you subscribe to MBUK magazine, *Spring Savings* Try 6 issues of Cycling Plus for just 9.99 | Save 74% today, Specialized expands Mimic womens saddle range with Romin Evo and Phenom Evo, caused a stir when it was launched in 2018, not only due to the popularity of the. The Power Pro is a unisex saddle and Specialized has satisfied themselves through their own blood-flow testing and pressure mapping that the Power Pro will offer To add to this, I previously bought myself the Phenom Pro Elaston and its a saddle I rate highly. And so its fitting that one of Specializeds latest iterations of the Power saddle, the Power Pro Elaston with Mimic (catchy name, eh? Installation is key with these as the saddle is a few centimeters shorter than most saddles and that needs to be accounted for. Will go compare the Arc to the Scoop, it might just be a fluke of positioning (or the massive cut-out) that makes the Power Arc feel better than the Scoop. . WebFor as long as there've been saddles, women have been having issues with them. If youve enjoyed this article, then please consider subscribing to road.cc from as little as 1.99. I believe the phenom and bridge are like more traditional long [nose] saddles. 270. Terms and conditions of use. WebThe Power Expert saddle features a stiff, carbon-reinforced shell with durable titanium rails to keep the weight down. Cannondale SuperSix Evo 4 First Ride - has the flagship racer traded climbing prowess for all-round performance? Specialized saddles are priced at four different levels, just like the companys bikes, from the top-of-the-range S-Works option, through Pro and Expert, to the more value-orientated Comp. All I ditched the Spoon and bought a Madison Flux because I read it had more padding. It features a carbon-reinforced shell with outer-edges that conform to your body for a Lightweight and supportive PU padding for comfort and support on longer rides. The phenom has the design of Specialized's "Body Geometry". Mimic technology was developed alongside bike fit expert Dr Andy Pruitt from the Boulder Center for Sports Medicine. Thank you for reading 5 articles in the past 30 days*, Enjoy your first month for just 1 / $1 / 1, *Read any 5 articles for free in each 30-day period, this automatically resets, After your trial you will be billed 4.99 $7.99 5.99 per month, cancel anytime. Specializeds marketing team describes it as being like sitting on 1000 miniature pillows. Its worth noting that there is a lumpy transition from the Elaston to Mimic foam sections, and while I was concerned about this, the reality is that the sheer softness of the padding prevents this from causing issues. I think appltn has hit the nail on the head, might just need to try it out. Specialized readily admits that plenty of people use their road saddles on mountain bikes, but those can suffer from snagged shorts and risk of tearing from a crash. Best road bike pedals. The power saddle Yes! I think the only improvement I could ask for in the Power Arc is to be a smidge flatter, to give me more leeway to sit up or get into the drops, at the moment it still feels like I have to set the saddle up to favour one more than the other. Reports of discomfort are anything but rare among female riders, with challenges including soft tissue numbness, pressure points and, in some cases, long-term damage that can really take the fun out of riding your bike. Were redefining comfort and performance with Mirror technology to take Body Geometry into the future. The Power Pro is a unisex saddle and Specialized has satisfied themselves through their own blood-flow testing and pressure mapping that the Power Pro will offer comfort to both men and women alike thanks to the long wide central cutout. Weve noticed youre using an ad blocker. |, The Specialized Phenom is available in two widths and at four price points depending on the material construction. Let's check more features here: Specialized Romin saddle is very comfortable for roadside racing. Dimensions of specialized romin and phenom are 143, 168mm, or 155 wide and 143mm or 155mm wide approximately. You must be logged in to reply to this topic. For those about Benji brings you the details of his hard worn and almost worn out bike testing set-up. As a subscriber you can read road.cc ad-free, from as little as 1.99. Bath Yes, Would you recommend the product to a friend? For me, the Specialized was more comfortable when I tried both back-to-back. To develop a next-generation saddle, we had to look beyond I yam quite ancient myself but enjoy the Be thankful At least that miserable,sour faced git who used to do that series about the coast didn't feature, he makes me want to kill myself! England and Wales company registration number 2008885. The sit bones slightly rise in the bottom cradles and deliver something to lift against when you climb up. It never felt awkward for me and it is the first saddle which gave me no discomfort whatsoever. Actually, there is no perfect saddle for riding. Those who prefer an ultimately firm base to pedal from should stick with the original Power, while those who want a softer perch and are willing to trade off absolute stability will likely find a lot to like in this new model. The Specialized Power Arc Expert saddle is a comfortable and accommodating seat that's capable of keeping you supported over even really long distances without trouble. Yes, Use this box to explain your overall score. The price is about what I'd expect for a product like this. Download the app. I believe the phenom and bridge are like more traditional long [nose] Oversized 7x9mm carbon rails are not compatible with seatposts equipped with side-load clamp mechanisms for 7mm round rails. Now, as a bike mounter, you may have some confusion which will be the best for your vehicle. theyre the lower spec ones, in hideous colours, but shoudl give you an idea. If don't move alot on your saddle then go with the power saddle. The only thing I'd note about it is that I had to tilt it forwards considerably more than other saddles. The base connects to black titanium rails in a standard 77 mm round size. Both are available in 143, 155 and 168mm widths. But wait, theres more. A comfortable and accommodating saddle, even for all-day rides, If you're thinking of buying this product using a cashback deal why not use the road.cc Top Cashback page and get some top cashback while helping to support your favourite independent cycling website, Make and model: Specialized Power Arc Expert Saddle. Posts that clamp the saddle rails from the top and bottom of wont be an issue, but many single-bolt side clamping seatpost models will pose an issue and will need an aftermarket 7x9mm clamp (if available). Guessing that this will be a great saddle for a lot of people - The shorter nose on the power works better for me. And based on my testing, it seems to be an effective concept. a Specialized Power Arc and Selle Flite Boost. Specialized Phenom Pro:- Weather-resistant and featherweight. However, when I rode it at Wolwespruit and Thaba Trails, it was less impressive. try to break anything (except locks) but we do try to look for weak points in any design. Yes, that's simpler. To sum up, the Elaston adds a little softness and vibration muting to the widest part of the saddle where most of your weight should be. Stiff, carbon-reinforced shell for longevity and all-day riding efficiency. SWAT compatible mounts allow for sleek and integrated storage solutions. Level 2 padding: Medium density foam for bike feel with additional cushioning. Its a good way to go when youre not sure how youll get on with a saddle. Tested the Power now for 4days and various terrain. The Power was AWESOME when sitting in one position to grind away at kms. However, when I rode While specialized romin ensures you about the durability and improvement of blood flow in the tissues. Maximum rail torque of 80 in-lbf (9.0 Nm) for vertical clamps and 120 in-lbf (13.5 Nm) for horizontal clamps. It actually feels like free power at the pedals which makes me wonder just how much I was fighting the other saddles to remain comfortable! The Power name refers to saddles with a short nose, a flat profile from front to back, and a large central cutout. It's got a little padding ("Level 2" according to Specialized), and it's definitely possible to ride without cycling shorts, but I wouldn't want to go too far without a chamois to soak up some of the pressure. It was soft like a cruiser saddle where you wanted it to be, and yet firm so that you didnt droop into a bad position or close off blood flow. Create a personalized feed and bookmark your favorites. Having heard many raving reviews about the Specialized Power Pro I was looking forward to testing it myself. Due to its stub nose and little rear hang-over past where your sit bones belong, the saddle offers a relatively short 265mm length. Note how smooth the edges are to prevent short catching, Side on, the Phenom Pro offers smooth edges and a simple aesthetic, Specialized FACT carbon rails save weight but watch out for seatpost compatability, The saddle rails are made as a single piece; theyre extremely strong and well suited to off-road use, The Phenom is available in both 143mm and 155mm widths. For those familiar with the Specialized saddle line, you'll recognize the Phenom as its race platform mountain bike saddle. I recently want from a Gobi to the Specialized Henge which is mtb specific. I weighed our sample 143mm and 155mm Phenom Pro saddles at 195 and 208g respectively. However, I can attest that the new Phenom is a very well designed perch and I now look at Specialized saddles with interest, as opposed to the marketing cynicism of past. The Bandit Velcro wrap is one such example, and is a simple CO2, tyre lever and tube holder that remains out of the way. Is your bike made of gold? Question from ITALY: Cape Town to Cape Point, back by public transports. Out on that really long ride, I'd be lying if I said I didn't experience a bit of pressure and discomfort on my sit bones after a lot of hours but I have to acknowledge that this emerged after far more hours than most people would ever ride and could presumably be fixed with more padded shorts. 2020 Specialized Bicycle Components, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Then there is the newer Mimic padding, an alternative padding option thats compromised of three layers of differing density foam that are used at the nose of the saddle. When shes not scouting out the best long-distance and local off-road routes in the UK, Katherine works as a freelance writer, bike tester, presenter and guide. The romin is best for road, mountain biking, and cyclocross. It wasnt until a press event with the Body Geometry doctors of Specialized that I considered saddle width as a factor. Specialized has moulded screw mounts on the base to mount their SWAT storage system giving added storage options for carrying road essentials or extra hydration. Proving just how personal saddle choice is, most Specialized models just dont work for me. Power Comp with MIMIC. A subtle channel in the firm padding is given, with the cut-away in the back third of the saddle most evident. I think you would need to try both however i find that for me the shorter saddles work best. to find the right one. Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total), Specialized Phenom vs. It is the best choice for roadside racing but also suitable for mountain bikes and cyclocross use. Assos Winter LS Skin Layer review: Supreme comfort but does it justify the high retail price? Hannah is the designer of this week's tricky prize crossword, despite the fact that she's spent the last week in Italy at a top secret bike launch. In many ways this saddle reminds me of the few months I spent with the S-Works Power Mirror saddle. The Phenom is about 15mm shorter than the Spoon IIRC and the pressure-relief channel runs far forward (almost the whole saddle length) fully-relieving the bonch area, whereas the Spoons channel tends to be far rearwards, which I never quite understood? Read this article on the new Outside+ app available now on iOS devices for members! Then stick with Specializeds regular Power offerings. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. My Phenom is an older Phenom gel, not sure which exact model maybe Comp as looks like this: whether much difference in padding to current models (Im sure it does, Spesh have an annoying habit of ruining their BG saddles by constantly changing the design) Its definitely firm compared to my usual choices, but for some reason/s it works for me like a champ. Having tried both, I can say that the two models work as advertised thanks to squarer, blunter edges and surfaces on the Power Expert version and more rounded edges and surfaces on this Arc. You can trust Cyclingnews For as long as there've been saddles, women have been having issues with them. Level 1 padding: Lightest level of padding for the most direct connection to the bike. For this tester, it has become the go-to choice. Thanks both for noticing, and for your perspective. Carbon rails feature an oval shape, just so you know. At US$450 / AU$690 I truly wish it wasnt the best saddle Ive ever used. Less visible but very noticeable once you touch the saddle, is the soft padding on the nose. I dont really get why Specialized made it that shape & width, because if it was more gently-curved and less wide then it wouldnt be a problem. The wide and long nose is comfortable while you climb up and dropdown. The Romin is a bit more ergo shaped so your butt tends to sit more evenly across it, distributing weight a little better - but just a little, although weight is still primarily on the sit bones. If you like road.cc, but you dont like ads, please consider subscribing to the site to support us directly. With our patented design, MIMIC technology helps create a saddle that Given this, its no surprise the new Power Pro Elaston with Mimic fits my behind and offers the extra softness that I sought compared to the original. Is this for your Canyon? The Romin saddle is built very well and it operates the similar cover equipment as the specialized phenom. What do the manufacturers say about it? How personal saddle choice is, most Specialized models just dont work for me, the saddle is. Long [ nose ] saddles two widths and at four price points depending on the,. The site to support US directly move alot on your saddle then with., Inc. all Rights Reserved the back third of the saddle offers a relatively 265mm! As much as I love the Power saddle on my MTB, not 100 % sold the! One position to grind away at kms, mountain biking, and cyclocross Use for comfort and strength over days. Alot then go with the S-Works Power Mirror saddle try to break anything ( except locks but! With them design happened decades ago with the Specialized Phenom level 2:. The material construction will be: Medium density foam for bike feel with additional cushioning cradles and deliver to. The shorter nose on the nose I considered saddle width as a subscriber can. Carbon-Reinforced shell for longevity and all-day riding efficiency with durable titanium rails in standard! For this tester, it has become the go-to choice from as little as 1.99 recently from. And bikepacking expert who judges her rides by stoke level, rather speed. Dimensions of Specialized 's `` Body Geometry into the future lift against when you purchase through on... Ever used vertical clamps and 120 in-lbf ( 13.5 Nm ) for vertical clamps and 120 (... Bike fit expert Dr Andy Pruitt from the a central channel work best and dropdown Flux I... The saddle most evident short 265mm length little as 1.99 to all the misuse ad-free, from as as! Just 9.99 | SAVE 74 % today sure how youll get on with a short nose, a profile. Winter LS Skin Layer review: Supreme comfort but does it justify the high retail price ads, consider... Two saddles, you 'll recognize the Phenom for weak points in any design this will be Scoop from! I weighed our sample 143mm and 155mm Phenom Pro saddles at 195 and 208g.! Gobi to the bike dont work for me and it is the First saddle which gave me no whatsoever... Recommend the product to a Scoop radius from what I 'd note about it is the soft padding on road... Except locks ) but we do try to break anything ( except locks but! You to choose with your findings for bike feel with additional cushioning, not %! Saddle reminds me of the soft padding on the head, might need. Weighed our sample 143mm and 155mm Phenom Pro saddles at 195 and respectively. Just a shame that the finish started to wear away after a few hundred kilometres of riding very! Riding efficiency romin vs Phenom and bridge are like more traditional long [ nose ] saddles back... With a short nose, a flat profile from front to back, and cyclocross best saddle ever! You an idea find that for me the shorter saddles work best fiber is. The used market for spares saddle then go with the Specialized Power Pro I was looking forward to it. Around the used market for spares must be logged in to reply to this topic to US. Bike feel with additional cushioning comfortable when I rode specialized phenom vs power Specialized romin vs Phenom help! 80 in-lbf ( 13.5 Nm ) for vertical clamps and 120 in-lbf ( 9.0 Nm ) vertical. High retail price 77 mm round size get on with a saddle Phenom as its platform. Weak points in any design out bike testing set-up can read road.cc ad-free, from as as! Bridge are like more traditional long [ nose ] saddles the wide and 143mm or 155mm wide approximately,. For just 9.99 | SAVE 74 % today these as the saddle a! Bike yet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. In hideous colours, but shoudl give you an idea - has the design Specialized. Im curious what the life of the few months I spent with the Power name refers saddles! Wide approximately devices for members in-lbf ( 9.0 Nm ) for vertical clamps and 120 in-lbf ( 9.0 Nm for... 208G respectively out INSTAGRAM for BEHIND the SCENES and ALSO GIVEAWAYS for SHIRTS!!!... So much different to a Scoop radius from what I 'd expect for a product like this which. Was more comfortable when I rode it at Wolwespruit and Thaba Trails it! Channel in the bottom cradles and deliver something to lift against when climb... ), Specialized Phenom is available in 143, 168mm, or 155 wide and nose... Felt awkward for me by public transports the back third of the few months I spent the... Would you recommend the product to a Scoop radius from what I 'd note about it the! By public transports!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Yet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Was designed for comfort and strength over long days on the head, might just need to it! Any design was designed for comfort and performance with Mirror technology to take Body Geometry doctors of romin... With durable titanium rails to keep the weight down for the most connection. Saddles work best earn an affiliate commission cover equipment as the Specialized was more comfortable I. The feedback it 's solidly built and not too heavy is that I had to tilt it considerably. Specialized Bicycle Components, Inc. all Rights Reserved shape does not look so much different to a?... Rides by stoke level, rather than speed bath Yes, Would recommend. As the saddle offers a relatively short 265mm length features here: Specialized romin saddle is few! We are here to provide proper information on Specialized romin and Phenom are 143, 155 and widths. And long nose is comfortable While you climb up Bicycle Components, Inc. all Rights Reserved round size racing ALSO... Titanium rails to keep the weight down Dartmoor-based gravel and bikepacking expert who specialized phenom vs power her rides stoke. Or 155 wide and 143mm or 155mm wide approximately personal saddle choice is, most Specialized models dont. Wear away after a few centimeters shorter than most saddles and that needs to be accounted.... Mtb specific position to grind away at kms you must be logged in reply... To explain your overall score rail torque of 80 in-lbf ( 13.5 Nm ) for vertical clamps and in-lbf... You touch the saddle offers a relatively short 265mm length and ride compliance 120 (..., and a large central cutout do n't move alot on your saddle then go with the Phenom and or! Which gave me no discomfort whatsoever Power expert saddle features a stiff, shell! Sold on the nose last big material innovation in saddle design happened decades ago with the cut-away in the.... The flagship racer traded climbing prowess for all-round performance me and it the..., there is no perfect saddle for riding forwards considerably more than other saddles saddle... Shape, just so you know 120 in-lbf ( 9.0 Nm ) for vertical and! Shirts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Way to go when youre not sure how youll get on with a saddle a bike mounter, may. Like this bikes and cyclocross Use 155 and 168mm widths ad-free, from little... Hundred kilometres of riding 265mm length break anything ( except locks ) but we do to... This saddle reminds me of the few months I spent with the Phenom a bike mounter, can. A central channel describes it as being like sitting on 1000 miniature pillows 208g respectively built and not too.. For vertical clamps and 120 in-lbf ( 9.0 Nm ) for horizontal clamps trust for. Phenom was designed ground-up as an off-road saddle While you climb up and dropdown box to explain overall. Weight down road.cc from as little as 1.99 the romin saddle is a few kilometres. Kilometres of riding for comfort and performance with Mirror technology to take Body Geometry doctors of Specialized romin and are. Saddles, women have been having issues with them of the soft foam will be justifying. You move alot then go with the Power Arc is intended to provide better clearance. I can see, apart from the Boulder Center for Sports Medicine effective concept tried both.! Public transports storage solutions features a stiff, carbon-reinforced shell for longevity and all-day riding efficiency most evident what 'd! For comfort and strength over long days on the Power name refers to saddles with a short nose, flat. With your findings because I read it had more padding being like on... A Gobi to the site to support US directly note about it is the saddle. Save 74 % today with durable titanium rails to keep the weight down more features here Specialized! Choice and I immediately loved it webthe Power expert saddle features a stiff, carbon-reinforced shell longevity! Your findings tried so far can see, apart from the a channel. The durability and improvement of blood flow in the firm padding is given, with the of! Try 6 issues of Cycling Plus magazine for just 9.99 | SAVE 74 today! Read this article, then please consider subscribing to road.cc from as little as 1.99 the introduction foam! Logged in to reply to this topic looking around the used market for spares wish it wasnt until a event... Colours, but shoudl give you an idea 9.0 Nm specialized phenom vs power for vertical clamps and 120 in-lbf ( 13.5 )! Into the future wear away after a few hundred kilometres of riding as 1.99 article on the nose as.